Australia mushroom trial dwell: Erin Patterson repeatedly accused of mendacity about beef wellington lunch in tense cross examination | Victoria
Take a look at our newest merchandise
![[Netflix Official & Auto Focus/Keystone] Smart Projector 4K Support, VOPLLS 25000L Native 1080P WiFi 6 Bluetooth Outdoor Projector, 50% Zoom Home Theater Movie Projectors for Bedroom/iOS/Android/PPT](https://i2.wp.com/m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71Emwd78tlL._AC_SL1500_.jpg?w=300&resize=300,300&ssl=1)
Erin Patterson repeatedly accused of mendacity about lunch by prosecution
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says Erin Patterson’s son gave proof that she didn’t inform him she was sick on the day of the lunch.
“I don’t know if I did or I didn’t,” Patterson says.
She says she wouldn’t have shared that together with her son’s pal.
Rogers says Patterson’s daughter gave proof that she believed her mom started to really feel sick the day after the lunch.
Patterson says she doesn’t know if she advised her daughter she was sick on the day of the lunch.
Rogers says Patterson’s son additionally gave proof that he noticed his mom on the Sunday – the day after the lunch – ingesting espresso within the morning.
Patterson says her son is mistaken.
Patterson’s son stated his mom stated she was feeling unwell and had diarrhoea. He stated his mom reported waking up in the course of the night time to make use of the bathroom and stated they might not be capable to go to church that morning.
Patterson says her reminiscence of this dialog is “very totally different”.
She says she got here downstairs and located her son within the TV room.
The very first thing he stated to me was one thing like: I’ve received a sore tummy.
Patterson says her son stated “can we not go to church?”.
Patterson says her son was the primary particular person to lift not attending church on Sunday.
“I recommend that’s a lie,” Rogers says.
“It’s not,” Patterson says.
Key occasions
Erin Patterson is requested about discharging herself from Leongatha hospital in opposition to medical recommendation.
She rejects a suggestion by prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC that she didn’t reply Webster’s calls or voicemails when she discharged herself.
Patterson says she responded twice to Dr Chris Webster’s calls by ringing the hospital.
Rogers says Patterson left Leongatha hospital at 8.10am and returned at 9.48am.
Patterson says she can’t keep in mind the particular time.
Erin Patterson says she advised physician she purchased most substances of lunch at Woolworths
The road of questioning turns to Patterson’s arrival at Leongatha hospital on 31 July 2023 – two days after the lunch.
Patterson arrived shortly after 8am, the courtroom hears.
She rejects that Dr Chris Webster requested her the place she purchased the mushrooms for the meat wellingtons.
Patterson says she remembers Webster asking if she purchased or made the meat wellingtons.
That caught in my reminiscence as a result of I didn’t know you could possibly purchase them pre-made.
Patterson says she advised him the vast majority of substances have been purchased from Woolworths.
Patterson recalled asking Webster why he thought the lunch attendees had consumed loss of life cap mushrooms.
She says he walked away and is not sure if he heard her.
Erin Patterson denies she was ingesting espresso two days after lunch
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC takes Erin Patterson to proof her kids gave in regards to the Monday following the Saturday lunch.
Erin’s daughter recalled seeing her mom ingesting espresso that morning, the courtroom hears.
Erin says she was sitting on the eating desk with a mug nevertheless it didn’t comprise espresso.
Her estranged husband, Simon Patterson, gave proof that Erin referred to as him that morning and stated she nonetheless had diarrhoea each 20 minutes and requested him to drive her to the hospital.
“I don’t keep in mind if I did that or not,” Erin says.
She says she can’t keep in mind if she talked about the frequency.
Erin agrees she requested Simon if he may drive her to the Leongatha hospital.
However she rejects that she advised him she couldn’t drive as a result of she was frightened about soiling herself.
Court docket reminded of prior proof that Erin Patterson didn’t use rest room in 90 minutes
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC takes Patterson to her son’s proof that he didn’t see his mom use the bathroom on the 90-minute one-way drive to his flying lesson in Tyabb on Sunday, 30 July 2023.
Patterson beforehand advised the courtroom that in this journey she went to the bathroom in a bush on the aspect of the freeway.
The flying lesson was cancelled because of poor climate, the courtroom hears.
Patterson says on the way in which again her son purchased her a espresso.
She says she had a “little” little bit of the espresso.
Erin Patterson rejects estranged husband’s proof about ‘poo my pants’ assertion
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says Erin Patterson’s son gave proof that he stated they didn’t have to go to his scheduled flying lesson however his mom was eager to take him.
Patterson agrees that she was “fairly eager to take him”.
Rogers takes Patterson to a telephone dialog she had together with her estranged husband Simon Patterson on 30 July 2023 – the day after the lunch.
Rogers asks if Patterson advised Simon she was having frequent diarrhoea, about each 20 minutes.
“I might need,” Patterson says.
Patterson rejects Simon’s proof that she advised him she had diarrhoea which started on the day of the lunch.
Rogers says Simon gave proof that Patterson advised him she was frightened she would “poo my pants” whereas driving.
“I didn’t inform him I used to be afraid I’d poo my pants, no,” Patterson says.
The courtroom has returned from a brief break and the prosecution is continuous its cross-examination of Erin Patterson.
Erin Patterson repeatedly accused of mendacity about lunch by prosecution
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says Erin Patterson’s son gave proof that she didn’t inform him she was sick on the day of the lunch.
“I don’t know if I did or I didn’t,” Patterson says.
She says she wouldn’t have shared that together with her son’s pal.
Rogers says Patterson’s daughter gave proof that she believed her mom started to really feel sick the day after the lunch.
Patterson says she doesn’t know if she advised her daughter she was sick on the day of the lunch.
Rogers says Patterson’s son additionally gave proof that he noticed his mom on the Sunday – the day after the lunch – ingesting espresso within the morning.
Patterson says her son is mistaken.
Patterson’s son stated his mom stated she was feeling unwell and had diarrhoea. He stated his mom reported waking up in the course of the night time to make use of the bathroom and stated they might not be capable to go to church that morning.
Patterson says her reminiscence of this dialog is “very totally different”.
She says she got here downstairs and located her son within the TV room.
The very first thing he stated to me was one thing like: I’ve received a sore tummy.
Patterson says her son stated “can we not go to church?”.
Patterson says her son was the primary particular person to lift not attending church on Sunday.
“I recommend that’s a lie,” Rogers says.
“It’s not,” Patterson says.
Erin Patterson says she does not know what was in her vomit day of the lunch
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says what Erin Patterson gave her kids weren’t her leftovers of the lunch.
“Incorrect,” Patterson says.
Rogers turns to Patterson’s proof that after the lunch she binge ate about two-thirds of an orange cake that her mom in legislation, Gail Patterson, had dropped at her home after which vomited.
Rogers asks whether it is Patterson’s proof that the vomit was “partly constituted by the meat wellington”.
Patterson says she has “no thought” what was within the vomit.
How may I? It’s vomit. Except you’ll be able to see a bean or a chunk of corn.
Rogers says “you didn’t have corn on the lunch”.
“That was an instance,” Patterson says.
Patterson says she doesn’t know what time she vomited. She agrees it was earlier than “supper time.”
In Australia, the Butterfly Basis is at 1800 33 4673. Within the UK, Beat could be contacted on 0808-801-0677. Within the US, assist is accessible at nationaleatingdisorders.org or by calling ANAD’s consuming problems hotline at 800-375-7767. Different worldwide helplines could be discovered at Consuming Dysfunction Hope
Erin Patterson denies mendacity to medical workers about how a lot of beef wellington she ate
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC asks Erin Patterson about how a lot of her beef wellington she ate on the lunch.
Rogers suggests Patterson ate her entire portion of beef wellington at lunch however advised Prof Rhonda Stuart, a health care provider at Monash hospital, that she solely ate half in an effort to clarify to medical authorities why her signs weren’t as critical because the lunch company.
“Incorrect,” Patterson says.
Pressed by Rogers that she beforehand gave proof that she didn’t keep in mind talking to Stuart, Patterson maintains that is her proof.
Rogers says Patterson advised Katrina Cripps, a toddler safety employee, that she solely ate half of her beef wellington.
Patterson says her reminiscence is she ate “about half” of her beef wellington.
Erin Patterson tells courtroom she doesn’t personal 4 of the identical plates
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says Simon Patterson gave proof that the day after the lunch Heather Wilkinson stated she recalled Patterson had served her beef wellington on a unique colored plate which was totally different to the opposite plates.
Simon additionally stated that on path to hospital Heather requested if Erin was wanting crockery and due to this fact wanted to make use of mismatched plates, Rogers says.
“Heather Wilkinson was right in her observations wasn’t she….” Rogers says.
“I don’t know,” Erin says.
Erin says she “doesn’t have an identical set of plates.”
I don’t have 5 plates the identical so any person would have had totally different plates.
I don’t have 4 plates the identical both.
Once I plated the meals, it wasn’t for explicit folks.
Erin Patterson tells courtroom Ian Wilkinson’s proof about her plates was incorrect
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC takes Erin Patterson to questions in regards to the plates used to serve the meat wellingtons on the fateful lunch on 29 July 2023.
Earlier within the trial, Ian Wilkinson stated Patterson served beef wellingtons for her company on 4 massive gray plates whereas she ate from a smaller “orangey-tan” colored plate. (Ian is Erin’s estranged husband’s uncle).
Rogers says Patterson’s proof that she solely had white, black and pink and black plates was a lie. Patterson rejects this.
Rogers asks if Patterson believes Ian gave incorrect proof in regards to the plates.
“Sure, I do,” Patterson replies.
Patterson says there have been no gray plates used.
Rogers asks if it was the case that “folks sat the place they favored” on the eating desk.
“Sure,” Patterson says.
Patterson rejects the suggestion by Rogers that she ate from a smaller plate.
Patterson says: “There was no smaller plate.”
Erin Patterson says she doesn’t keep in mind ever visiting web site iNaturalist
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC takes Erin Patterson to a digital report of a pc that police seized from her home per week after the lunch.
The courtroom beforehand heard that digital data from the pc confirmed it had been used to go to webpages itemizing sightings of loss of life cap mushrooms on the citizen science web site iNaturalist in Might 2022.
Patterson says she doesn’t keep in mind ever visiting iNaturalist.
Rogers says Patterson was conversant in the web site as a result of she entered it because the search time period on the search engine.
“I must disagree,” Patterson says.
Requested about her curiosity in loss of life cap mushrooms, Patterson says she solely wished to know whether or not they grew in South Gippsland.
The courtroom has beforehand heard {that a} URL visited minutes afterwards on the identical pc on 28 Might 2022 appeared to point out an order for meals had been positioned on the Korumburra Center Lodge.
Rogers says Patterson positioned this order.
Patterson says “I don’t know.”
As Rogers strikes to a brand new subject, Patterson begins to interject a couple of “second go to to Bricker Reserve.”
Rogers says “I’m the one who asks the questions.”
Erin Patterson cross-examined about proof concerning weight reduction surgical procedure appointment
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC says on Friday Erin Patterson advised the jury she had a pre-surgery appointment for gastric bypass process for weight reduction on the Enrich clinic in Melbourne. She stated it was booked for September 2023.
Rogers says the clinic supplies providers in beauty surgical procedure.
“I don’t know,” Patterson says.
Rogers says Patterson cancelled the September appointment.
Rogers places to Patterson: “The Enrich clinic doesn’t supply gastric bypass surgical procedure … Agree or disagree?”
“I don’t know,” Patterson says.
Rogers says the clinic additionally doesn’t supply appointments for gastric bypass surgical procedure or gastric sleeve surgical procedure.
“I don’t know,” Patterson says.
I’m a bit puzzled.
Rogers says the appointment had “nothing to do with gastric bypass surgical procedure”.
Patterson says it “would have been associated to weight-loss surgical procedure”.
I used to be wanting into liposuction as effectively.
Rogers says Patterson’s proof that she had an appointment on the clinic for gastric bypass surgical procedure was a lie.
Patterson says it “wasn’t a lie”.
That’s what my reminiscence was.
The jurors have entered the room in Morwell.
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC is cross-examining Erin Patterson, who’s wearing a darkish paisley shirt.
Whereas we look ahead to proceedings to start, here’s a recap of what the jury heard on Friday:
1. Erin Patterson stated she couldn’t recall accessing posts about loss of life cap mushroom sightings on the citizen science web site iNaturalist in Might 2022.
2. Patterson stated on 1 August 2023 – three days after the lunch – she realised foraged mushrooms might have been in a Tupperware container storing store-bought mushrooms and used within the beef wellingtons. This occurred after her estranged husband Simon Patterson requested if she used a dehydrator to poison his dad and mom, Erin stated. She agreed she didn’t inform anybody about this realisation.
3. Beneath cross-examination, Erin denied that the aim of the fateful lunch on 29 July 2023 was to debate recommendation a couple of medical problem she had. Erin acknowledged she advised Simon about “some medical stuff” when she invited him to the lunch about two weeks prior.
4. Erin says the medical points referred to gastric bypass surgical procedure for weight reduction she was planning to have. She stated she had a pre-surgery appointment booked for this.
5. Erin stated she felt “ashamed” a couple of message she despatched to her Fb pals in December 2022 the place she wrote “fuck em” in relation to her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson. She rejected the prosecution’s suggestion that messages in a bunch Fb chat mirrored her true emotions in direction of Don and Gail.
Welcome to day 29 of Erin Patterson’s triple-murder trial
Patterson, who started testifying on Monday afternoon, will return to the witness field for a fifth day.
Prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC will proceed cross-examining Patterson.
The trial, which is in its sixth week, will resume from 10.30am.
Patterson, 50, faces three prices of homicide and one cost of tried homicide referring to a beef wellington lunch she served at her home in Leongatha in regional Victoria on 29 July 2023.
She is accused of murdering her in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, and her estranged husband’s aunt, Heather Wilkinson. The tried homicide cost pertains to Heather’s husband, Ian.
She has pleaded not responsible to the fees.
The prosecution alleges Patterson intentionally poisoned her lunch company with “murderous intent”, however her attorneys say the poisoning was a tragic accident.
![[Win 11&Office 2019] 14″ Rose Gold FHD IPS Display Ultra-Thin Laptop, Celeron J4125 (2.0-2.7GHz), 8GB DDR4 RAM, 1TB SSD, 180° Opening, 2xUSB3.0, WIFI/BT, Perfect for Travel, Study and Work (P1TB)](https://i3.wp.com/m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71CzO7Oc8jL._AC_SL1500_.jpg?w=300&resize=300,300&ssl=1)
